4.5 I really, really liked this one. It was sweet but heart wrenching at the same time. In the end it's a great Christmas novella and it made me happy.The only thing that really bothered me was how the two MCs didn't recognize each other when they saw each other after 12 years. Yes, 12 years is a lot, but like Mitch said, at one point they were the most important person for one another. I don't understand how you can forget someone who means so much to you. Web also said that he saw Mitch in some magazine and he went to watch him dance once. And afterwards, when Mitch saw everyone he used to know 12 years ago, they all recognized him at first glance. So yeah, that didn't quite make sense to me.